Jump to content

hugocoolens

Members
  • Posts

    44
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by hugocoolens

  1. On 4/3/2023 at 5:05 PM, attila said:

    Hi 

    1,2. The real characteristics are measured but not with step Ib but Vrb. The Ib results from the drop across the Rb reference resistor, like in the drawings on the right:
    3. Yes

    image.png

    image.png

    Thanks for answering. Let's agree to disagree on this, but I wouldn't call this "the real" output characteristics because when you look them up in a datasheet the output characteristics will always be given with a stepped Ib (thus making them independent from a Vrb and rb).  It would of course be interesting to see how much they differ from each other for certain values.

    kind regards,

    Hugo

  2. On 3/27/2023 at 3:21 PM, hugocoolens said:

    Does this mean that the output characteristics Ic=f(Vce) are not given for fixed steps of Ib as it is on a regular curve tracer? Is there a method to (post)process the data such that we get "regular" output characteristics (i.e. one characteristic for each fixed Ib value) ?

     

    kind regards,

    Hugo

    So, may I conclude?:

    1. The software does not display the real output characteristics when using the curve tracer module

    2. It is not possible to display the real output characteristics with the curve tracer module

    3. To display the real output characteristics a stepped current source for Ib would be  necessary

    Can anyone here confirm this?

    kind regards,

    Hugo

  3. On 8/27/2021 at 12:25 PM, attila said:

    Hi @hugocoolens

    I don't know from which instrument you want to export.
    Like in Network Analyzer uncheck Magnitude and leave Phase, File/Export or Channel2 gear/Export, uncheck unneeded Options

    image.png.73aef4560f4f64085367d11199ac09ce.png

    image.png.a4f036c9cf967ced1c2332ff44199fb2.png

     

    You could also use a Script for custom file saves, like:
    image.png.3d4dc4e8b59c4443ab74b67264230501.png

    image.png.74bfe2a1ec1fd940417adeef14c46ebe.png

    image.png.6b0b332dcc79c3fbd6488ee12f1af565.png

    Dear Attila,

    Thanks for taking the time to answer, unfortunately you misunderstood my question. My question concerned the phase 180° discontinuities which appear in phase in characteristics of higher order filters. Look e.g. in the csv-fragment below:

    Frequency (Hz),Channel 2 Magnitude (dB),Channel 2 Phase (*)

    67.84039429151049,32.33863058034709,-115.0260967835472
    69.41950372042898,32.82012692658842,-116.6902265699424
    71.0353698134933,33.35998288920216,-118.4767475993952
    72.68884814938258,33.86949926656823,-120.4429189376033
    74.38081422193648,34.42710393401945,-123.0032131846593
    76.11216390371717,35.01807311003826,-125.6403202728387
    77.88381392036204,35.60595461974825,-128.8409191851678
    79.6967023359762,36.23069593730597,-132.2874092457207
    81.55178904982499,36.83287768063549,-136.609505586391
    83.45005630458739,37.4432129685337,-141.4554223529707
    85.39250920643975,38.00862023330612,-147.1141472300344
    87.3801762572454,38.51766449352777,-153.2963667607696
    89.41410989913213,38.89978927587817,-159.9990032507159
    91.49538707174641,39.20806992784435,-167.2649998957178
    93.6251097824769,39.3679758620025,-174.6532900565014
    95.80440568995267,39.38339174460207,178.2076882057428
    98.03442870112301,39.29580965462377,171.2321917374081
    100.3163595822344,39.08330573023837,164.4734535672866
    102.6514065840309,38.77847248087976,158.4707624675104
    105.0408060815049,38.4234657631503,153.0376864214749
    107.4858232285421,38.00415850907009,147.7992136217931
     

    The value for the frequency of 95.80440568995267 Hz, has such a 180° phase discontinuity. The phase is given as: 178.2076882057428° but I'd prefer it as: -181.7923118...° i.e. the given value (and all following values) minus 360°, that way the phase characteristic becomes continuous.

    The strange thing is, that Waveforms is "aware" of this issue as it is possibe to display  the phase characteristic  without 180° discontinuities by entering an appropriate offset and range.

    kind regards,

    Hugo

     

×
×
  • Create New...